Pay-Go Redux

With Congress looking at a hefty bill for Hurricane Irene relief the budgetary fighting has begun, with Minority Leader Cantor talking about imposing “pay-go” rules on such spending. From Politico:

But on Fox News earlier Monday, Cantor said, “There’s a federal role, yes we’re going to find the money, we’re just going to need to make sure that there are savings elsewhere to continue to do so.”

These spending principles are certain to run into political reality, as Irene could test the political viability of Republican orthodoxy as lawmakers try to weigh the emotional reaction to American communities in need while trying to stay true to their conservative fiscal ideals.

Under Republican notions of “pay-go” any such “disaster spending” would need to be offset by spending reductions elsewhere in the budget. And Cantor seems to be indicating that will be the case here. Under the original “pay-go” rules that were actually followed for a time in the 90’s any such spending would need to be offset by spending reductions or tax increases. That last part of the equation always made Republicans squirm, and the first part always made Democrats squirm. So in the interests of bipartisanship “pay-go” was eviscerated by declaring this type of spending an “emergency” and exempting it from pay-go. But once Congress got the flavor for emergency declarations they started declaring routine spending “emergencies”, including defense appropriations, and presto chango pay-go was gone in fact.

As a Mayor I believe that the federal government has an obligation to help municipalities and states deal with emergencies, and I hope that Irene will not be an exception. I do believe, however, that Congress should go back to pay-go, and strictly enforce its provisions. It would impose badly needed discipline on Congress, and force them to make tough choices. And the Republicans are going to have to make some tough choices here. They run the House. Lets see how they deal with all the damage done in the districts of Republicans in Congress.

This entry was posted in National News and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Pay-Go Redux

  1. Jules Gordon says:

    Your Honor,
    I will watch, along with you and let’s see what happens.

    Talk about dumb things. Here is a lesson that shows Government doesn’t know diddly about “green jobs”.

    Deval’s solar power favorite lost some 50 million dollars of Massachusetts “investment”. Now the President’s favorite,Solyndra,has just gone bankrupt.

    Just think of all the million of dollars that would would have been available for you and your fellow city and town managers and Mayors for clean up if we hadn’t “invested” in those looser companies.



  2. Derek Jackson says:

    Another hurricane about to hit the south and may head up the northeast corridor… and another one might hit the east coast and go right up the northeast corridor. At least my flood insurance is paid up.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s